Simple guide on how to catch the 4 fish required for the fisherman’s side quest.
The Fisherman NPC is found early in the game at the southeast edge of Pilgrim’s Passage. He asks you to bring him a series of fish, that being the lobster, squid, octopus, and crab. He will reward you with a holy talisman piece for each fish you bring. Once you have brought him all fish, he will open a shop to sell fish to you.
How to Fish
Fishing in Cult of The Lamb is incredibly simple. All you have to do is keep the hook inside the green bar as it moves up and down. Keeping the hook inside the green area will reel the fish in, and once it is close enough, you will catch it! It may take some practice, but once you get the hang of it you can do it consistently.
While creating a new doctrine, you have 5 options to choose from. Simply level up sustenance to level 3 to unlock the Ritual of The Ocean’s Bounty. This ritual will double the amount of fish caught for 2 days, and will greatly increase the chance for special fish (such as the lobster)! From my experience, this is also a fantastic way to farm coins.