In total, you can do eight possible endings to get the Completionist Achievement in Hooked on You. However, there are other storylines you can unlock to gain hidden rewards that reveal the secrets of Murderer’s Island.
The Huntress’ mannerisms are almost similar to The Trapper since she likes strong individuals that perfect the precision minigames. But, on the contrary, she loves the concept of family and any conversations about having children.
Before we start with this list of conclusions, players should know that the questionnaire at the beginning doesn’t affect anything and we won’t include any answers for that part of the storyline.
Good Ending for The Huntress
Here are the dialogue selections you should pick for the first day on Murderer’s Island:
- Toss it back
- Choose the image of a volleyball net on the beach
- Pick The Huntress icon twice
- “I’m sorry”
- Accept the jerky from The Huntress
- Show her a thing or two
- Choose The Huntress for storytime
- Join in on singing
- “No way! How cool!”
- Chuckle awkwardly
On day two, choose The Huntress to go on a date. Here is what you must say to win her over:
- “It’s so… much!”
- Grab a shashka
- “Of course!”
- “UGH. As if…”
- “Thanks, but no thanks”
- Pick any decisions at The Huntress’ Cabin
- Tell of your brush with death
- “Fine, I’ll tell a story”
- Choose The Huntress again for storytime/hangout event
- Angler Fish Mask
- Any decision will do when The Huntress flirts with you
At the bar, The Huntress will test out your mushroom knowledge by asking you which ones are safe to eat. Here is the correct order you must do:
- Left (icon on the most left)
Once you do this mini quiz, tell her, “They ARE hot aren’t they?” and “Kill ’em all.” Then, the elimination round will begin, and you can decide on anyone you want, except for The Huntress.
Your time on Murderer’s Island is almost up, and you must follow these directions to get The Huntress’ good ending. First, give her the flower to begin your date and select these social interactions:
- Tidy up/Freak out (doesn’t affect anything)
- “HELL YES!”
Next, you’ll participate in finding The Huntress’ stolen treasure at Trapper’s Cave, Spirit’s Lighthouse, Wraith’s Cosmic Dump, and Trickster’s Stage. The only one you need to worry about is Trapper’s Cave, where you’ll need to select “Underground Tunnel” to survive his attacks.
Afterward, The Huntress’ mother will approach the both of you at her cabin. These are the dialogue options you’ll have to pick:
- “What an honor!”
- “Of Course!”
- “To start a family together”
- “I LOVE YOU TOO!”
If you’ve done all these talking points, you should now have The Hunger achievement.
One of the last interactions with The Huntress can either give you the good or bad ending. You must choose “LAUGH IN HER FACE!” if you want to gain The Horror achievement, resulting in you becoming the villain in the story and breaking her heart.